Flexibility Drives the Rise of CFD Trading Across Mexico

Mexican investors have been relatively limited in the number of options they have over the years, being mainly limited to the local bolsa, fixed-income securities, and the occasional foraging into mutual funds run by local banks. That landscape has changed significantly. A more digitally-linked generation of traders is growing younger and it is finding more instruments that can be more agile and the numbers indicate that desire. Sites that provide entry to international markets have been cataloging a drastic rise in Mexican account openings, and most users have been drawn to contracts for difference to engage in international price movements without needing to own the underlying asset.

Image Source: Pixabay

The attractiveness is based on something real. An example of a trader at Guadalajara can buy in the morning on the oil prices, sell in the afternoon on the European indices, and close all positions at the end of day, without having to maneuver currency conversion obstacles or global brokerage accounts, which entail volumes of documentation. This operational freedom has until recently been the preserve of institutional desks or high net worth individuals having complex advisory services. Now it is in an app on a smart phone. The retail involvement in derivative-type products has been steadily rising over the last six years and this structural change, although gradual, has been undeniable and reflects the trends already apparent in Brazil, Colombia and Chile.

The most interesting part of the case of Mexico is the impact of the financial literacy campaigns, most of which are not official, in the expedited adoption. YouTube and Telegram channels that analyze the market have developed audiences of up to hundreds of thousands of followers who have never formally studied economics, breaking down technical ideas into Spanish that the audience can easily understand. Hosts take one through concepts such as leverage, margin calls and spread management in the same informal style of explaining a football match. How far this organic training is adequate preparation in actual capital at risk is another question, but it has little to say against its effect on curiosity and first involvement.

One of the more subtle lines running throughout this story is regulatory clarity or the quest to find it. The Comisión Nacional Bancaria y de Valores has traditionally been concerned with safeguarding retail clients against unlicensed groups and the emergence of offshore sites has created a regulatory vacuum which government bodies are yet to overcome. The platforms in operation in Mexico are licensed in the Cayman Islands, the United Kingdom or Cyprus, a fact that complicates investor protection in practical terms. Those traders who recognize this dynamic are more likely to approach it with eyes open and pick brokers on the basis of reputation, third-party audit and community response as opposed to thinking that domestic oversight is relevant. Things are changing and industry observers see more formal guidance by Mexican regulators in the coming years.

Simultaneously with the regulatory discourse, CFD trading has generated a real discussion between the economists and market commentators regarding its overall impact on the financial well-being. Critics suggest product structure can increase the magnitude of the losses especially when leverage is involved, which could not be predicted by the non-expert users. Those in favor of it argue that it has access to global instruments which ordinary Mexican savers could not have access to before, and this enables them to diversify their portfolio which domestic-only portfolios cannot do. They both have some merit, and the ground truth is usually more complicated than either of the camps is willing to admit. Other traders have quietly accumulated substantial amounts of supplementary income over the years; some have lost savings that they could not afford to gamble. The trend is not exclusive to Mexico, but the magnitude of new actors is worth studying closely.

Technology has influenced not only the access, but the behavior. The mobile-first platforms have re-architected the trading experience to be speedy and simple with interfaces that emphasize one-tap trading over the sophisticated order management systems of the professional traders. The philosophy of this design fits best into the user base that moves back and forth between other engagements, lunch, late at night, or on weekend mornings when domestic markets are closed. The openness of some international markets, especially forex and commodities contracts fits this lifestyle. It further implies that events that move markets in Asia or Europe might have an impact on the open positions of Mexican traders whilst they sleep, which is a risk aspect platform tutorials do not necessarily cover with adequate prominence.

In a bigger perspective, the trend of CFD trading in Mexico illustrates something bigger than a product category taking off. It signifies a redefinition of who has a right to access global capital markets and on what conditions. There is now the infrastructure in place where a retail trader in Monterrey can respond to an announcement of the Federal Reserve at the same speed as someone in London with the same price feeds and analytical tools. What remains unknown is whether that democratization will eventually become beneficial to Mexican traders, based on far more than just technology: financial education, personal risk tolerance, and the regulatory environment which is yet to form around them.